Review:
Is there a point at which the amount of paper used in publishing
global warming books actually increases temperature? The vast
number that appear annually usually go over the same ground
with only a few variations. True, we are seeing a change in
ideas. The straight science texts are now sharing places with
those of a more practical orientation. Initially, this contained
books dealing with mitigation and then adaptation but now the
focus is on reduction. In many ways this is in keeping with
the main trends of groups like the IPCC where it was once thought
that the process could be reversed and now the idea is trying
to adapt and reduce the impact as far as possible. Amongst the
welter of texts, this one takes a very practical viewpoint -
how to make a personal contribution to using less "carbon".
Sub-titled
'my attempt to live a low-carbon life and what it cost', the
author seeks to describe the changes needed to reduce his (and
his family's) environmental impact which is what is usually
inferred when discussing 'carbon reduction'. The basic premise
of the book is quite straightforward - the author will try to
research and document his personal attempts to reduce emissions
in the course of one year. He sets a target and then examines
how far he can go and how practical it is to reach that target.
The book's introduction sets out this personal challenge and
the reasons behind it (both personal and environmental). Chapter
two expands upon the background to this quest. It describes
the economic climate (i.e. the recent drop in the global economy
- 'the global financial crisis'), the planet's climate (the
patterns of global warming) and some of the new players on the
block who cannot be ignored - India and China. From this point
on, the text describes the various parts of the author's life
that are being scrutinised. The first one is food. Chapter three
describes UK food consumption and then looks at its greenhouse
gas production. This is followed by the author's own changes
and what impact such changes made to both his life and to emissions
reduction. Chapter four looks at his travel patterns and what
can be done to reduce impact. It's worth noting here, although
it is seen elsewhere, that there is a very pragmatic approach
being taken. Changes must be positive and they must also be
sustainable in the long term. This is as much a lifestyle choice
as well as a carbon one. The reader is made well aware that
change is most likely to succeed if it has a big benefit for
a little cost. The hair-shirt approach is out because it won't
last but a few changes, often with associated health benefits
(walk don't ride) will. Chapter five is an exploration of one
of the main energy wasters, the home. After looking again at
the national situation, we are shown how a typical London home
can be cost-effectively retro-fitted to reduce energy use. The
debates over wall insulation and double glazing are typical.
The range of possibilities is carefully reduced until a decent
compromise has been worked out. Chapter six takes the same approach
to electricity consumption which is a major source of carbon
emissions but for which not everybody has a ready substitute.
Chapter seven continues the theme by looking at the waste cycle
and how it can be reduced. What's interesting here as elsewhere
is that there are savings with virtually no cost - recycling
is an obvious, easy option but so is re-using rather than consuming
and replacing. Leisure is the next subject. The author's air
travel is a major drawback but at least the same honest approach
is taken and the explanation (family business) is plausible
- the reader can empathise as we've all had similar situations
that can't be avoided. A final chapter summarises what happened,
comments and provides us with a final balance sheet.
One
of the personal issues with global warming is that I've been
dealing with it for 35 years and those coming fresh to it often
assume everyone else is too. Thus, for me, it's hard to find
a new angle and, I must admit, it's the expectation I used when
planning this review. Slowly but surely I was persuaded otherwise.
The down to earth writing - light but still serious - was a
delight to read and the journey seems all too familiar. The
text is loaded with data (all easily referenced which is a big
bonus) which make it easy to follow the argument. Chapters have
a good common thread of UK situation, personal change and summary
at the end which makes it an easy read. From a general reader
viewpoint it is a very good book. However, putting on an educational
perspective it becomes a great book. There's so much in it with
so many practical ideas that any educator could come at this
aspect of environmental education from any subject. Students
woulsd easily be hooked on this book because they can all try
to follow the same ideas the author did. Overall, this is a
surprise of a text, one of the best I've reviewed this year
and certainly a definite must-buy for the institution and personal
library.