Review:
Urban studies are becoming increasingly popular especially as
we are now officially an urban species. Likewise, there are
many texts dealing with urban ecosystems and the slightly newer
view of urban ecology. This suggests there are two 'cities':
the natural system which attempts to "take over" built
forms and the human system which erects buildings partly to
escape (or at least mitigate) the natural environment. What
these perspectives have in common is that they focus on one
area. However, it is possible to make the case that since natural
and human-made are together in one space it makes sense to deal
with them as one inter-related system. It is this integration
that the authors argue for. They posit that we need to study
the connections between natural and artificial, between "North"
and "South" cities and between action and effect.
To tie this together the authors use the term human urban environment.
Chapter
one takes the reader rapidly through the historical development
and spread of the city, its footprint, its management and its
sustainability. The aim is to give the reader some of the background
needed to understand the more technical material that follows.
Chapter two continues this introductory theme but from the focus
of defining (or more accurately de-constructing) the term 'human
urban environment'. In addition, the chapter highlights some
key issues often left out of texts, notably the plurality of
responses i.e. "North" and "South" form
a continuum not two groupings. Most importantly, there is a
detailed discussion on the notion of "critical perspectives"
as a way to better appreciate the inter-relations between natural
and human systems. Chapter three looks at the changes in city
through time. This is not the measured step found in many historical
geography texts but a series of steps from the early city through
industrial city to new 'green city: a series of transitions
between forms. These transitions are described in terms of both
topic e.g. spatial, environmental, resource etc. and geographical
e.g. North/South. If chapter three is time, chapter four is
the companion dealing with space. It discusses growing urbanisation
and its effects, employment, land use, tenure and governance.
If these four chapters describe in broad terms the development
of the current city the next four examine key drivers of change
in the hunan-urban system. Chapter five takes the city as a
series of resource flows taken largely from the surrounding
ecosystems. In turn this leads to discussions about then use
of these resources and the resulting pollution and environmental
impacts. Again, the North/South debate continues but with more
emphasis on the 'green' Northern development set against the
'brown' South development i.e. post-industrial versus industrialisation
to develop (and presumably subsequently follow the 'green' path
assuming there is such a linear track. Chapter six looks at
urban growth and development starting with housing and tenure
and contrasting the responses between the various city systems
and finishing with ideas on sustainable urban form. Chapter
seven studies urban economics and the impact that industrialisation
has and can have on the city and its inhabitants. Finally in
this part, chapter 8 examines the social environment and the
dimensions of health, poverty etc. that can overwhelm cities.
This ties in with environmental crimes and justice and risks
suffered by the weaker groups especially women and children.
Chapters 9 and 10 take these issues and suggest how they can
be dealt with practically. Chapter 9 considers the range of
tools that can be used to assess urban conditions e.g. polluter
pays principle, cost-benefit analysis; the ways in which information
can be gathered and some of the ideas that can be used to generate
change. Assuming that the correct city of the future is a sustainable
one, chapter 10 outlines the pressures it might be under and
how it can be achieved. Alongside
the details in each chapter are the common threads of case studies,
overviews and references/links.
This
is a remarkable book. It looks at the urban-ecology interface
in a new way which allows a thorough examination of the system
whilst using a holistic technique. This technique is constantly
re-worked through the text so that the reader can see how it
applies to any one specific area. It's full of good ideas and
practical suggestions which make it ideal for the beginner trying
to assess the environmental impact of their surroundings. Given
that we are an urban species this makes sense not least because
we need to address the situation that old city thinking has
brought about. This is a bright and refreshing look at a familiar
topic and a very interesting methodology. Certainly one of the
best books published this year and a definite must-buy for the
library.