Review:
As I write this review I have next to me a very battered copy
of the second edition. It started me along the ecological education
trail and although I didn't realise it at the time it was one
of three ecological perspectives that have developed since the
1970s. The other two: Odum's energetics approach and the developmental
perspective of Begon et al have provided generations of students
with a sound but subtly changing approach to basic ecology.
From
the personal we turn to the pragmatic. Gone is the quaint typeface
and small black-and-white illustrations of the second edition,
replaced by the usual full-colour visual treatment expected
these days. What's not gone is the same Eltonian approach he
has always adopted (and updated). As one might expect, there
are numerous changes (even from the fifth edition which was
reviewed here) but these seem to be more of re-grouping rather
than complete change. As always we open with a chapter looking
at the nature of ecology and how it operates. Two subsequent
chapters look at changes in populations through evolution and
behaviour. Whilst this might seem less usual, there are sound
reasons. Often we assume (and certainly students do) that species
remain constant and everything around changes. The principle
of uniformitarianism
is strong and not easy to discount and yet we must be aware
that organisms can and do change. It now makes sense to study
such changes first to see if they are responsible for and ecological
responses. These three chapters form a group in the text. Part
two focusses of the geography of distributions. An initial chapter
examines how one analyse distribution and some of the conceptual
issues involved. This is followed by two complementary chapters
which describe, respectively biotic and abiotic limitations
to distribution. A final chapter, seven, analyses the combined
impact of these. The remainder of the text is divided into two
further parts which mirror the subtitle of the book - abundance
and distribution. Whichever approach one takes and however one
analyses fieldwork, ultimately ecology must come down to these
two factors - how many and where are they. Part three starts
with a look at population from demographic and mathematical
perspectives. This is followed by a study of the mathematics
of population growth and some of the basic formulae we use.
It can be argued that this sets the scene for the remainder
of this part. The framework is there - we need mathematical
models and an appreciation of how they operate but the need
is to discover how ecological principles work in the field and
influence real populations. The next four chapters are linked
and follow a common theme of interactions. Chapter 10 describes
interactions due to competition in both plants and animals.
Chapter 11 adds predation to the list of variables whilst chapter
12 considers changes in (external?) responses of herbivory and
mutualism. Finally in this set, chapter 13 highlights the (internal?)
changes brought about by diseases and parasites. Before examining
some applied aspects of abundance, the author provides a 'linking'
chapter 14 discussing issues of population regulation. What
limits populations and how might they be explained? Population
numbers are important not just for ecological theory but also
because a large part of human existence is based on manipulation
of organism numbers (otherwise known as fishing, farming and
conservation). It's these three examples that the next chapters
examine. Thus chapter 15 highlights concepts like maximum sustainable
yield and resource efficiency; chapter 16 describes the pros
and cons of pest control whilst chapter 17 looks at issues surrounding
small population analysis and genetic diversity. The final group
of chapters relates to distribution. A very useful, compact
study of Mt St Helens and a side view at Surtsey demonstrates
the issue of succession which is all too clear in these volcanic
settings. If this is change in time then chapter 19 which is
change in space should be zonation but it's actually given up
to biodiversity. This is an interesting choice. Both conventional
zonation studies and current ideas on biodiversity (especially
under global warming scenarios) run on gradients. Thus using
a current theme to illustrate an older idea works on two levels:
catching the student's attention and getting across ecological
ideas. The next two chapters tackle a common theme - dynamics
at the community level. The first considers issues from species
interactions in equilibrial communities whilst the latter examines
what might happen in a nonequilibrium setting. In a similar
fashion, the next three chapters consider the concept of community
metabolism firstly through primary and then secondary production
with a final look at sources of nutrients in nutrient cycles.
The two final chapters study two of the most important ecological
issues today: climate change and ecosystem health. Global warming
is affecting both abundance and distribution which makes it
easy to fit into this text's themes. Ecosystem health (or services)
is a major issue in better using and managing our ecosystems.
Each
chapter is packed with features to help the reader. We start
with key concepts and terms, go through richly illustrated pages
to summaries, review questions and some suggested readings.
There are also a series of text boxes dealing with a range of
topics from advanced parts of the text, to profiles of leading
ecologists to essays on key issues. Overall, this retains the
approach which made it a standard in the 1970s. It's been updated
thoroughly as one might expect in both production standards
and, obviously, concept. As an outstanding example of one of
ecology's key texts it should be expected to be found on every
institution (and ideally personal) library. An absolute must-buy.