Review:
One of the delights and also downsides of environmental science
(and to a lesser extent applied ecology) is that to make any
headway one needs to be aware of a wide range of topics. This
has been commented on before - environmental science is not
the weak alternative in education but the far more difficult
one because of its inter-relatedness and complexity. To help,
it is necessary to have guides to related topics to see which
areas are of importance and how the topic is developing. Currently,
Sage is publishing a range of these texts and the most relevant
will be reviewed here.
By
now, the global warming debate should be so firmly entrenched
as a political issue that texts on political geography should
be seen as essential rather than ephemeral. Not all texts are
equal and so one outlining the fundamentals should be of use.
This text attempts to do that for a very wide range of political
topics. 28 contributions are divided into 6 sections, the first
of which is statecraft - the collection and distribution of
power in a given area. States are fundamental spatial units
in political geography and their construction helps or inhibits
a given line of thought. Even with increases in supranational
forms of power like the European Union, nations are still important
power blocs. To rule a state one needs sovereignty set in a
system of governance and it is these four issues that this section
discusses. Part two focusses on power. If we assume that one
aim of a nation is to gain/maximise power over its people and
other states then the distribution of power is an important
issue. Within this section the four key elements - hegemony,
territory, geopolitics and superpowers are analysed. It could
be argued that this should really be two pairs with territory
being a more localised version of geopolitics whilst the pursuit
of power is the realm of hegemony and superpowers. Part three
takes a more temporal turn with an examination of the ideas
of modernity. Given the somewhat longer timespan of the last
500 years, this part looks at how states have grown their power
bases and how this has, in turn, affected other nations. As
such, this is an extension of the ideas in parts one and two.
We started with the individual state and how it was constructed
and then moved on to the way it can gather (or lose if on the
other side!), power. Now we are looking at the growth of spatial
power. A central argument here is that it's only modern states
that have had the capacity and organisation to construct power
extra-territorially. Colonialism is one such phenomenon but
this has needed some part of the colonial nation to be present
in the colony. In contrast ideology, also discussed here, is
just the exchange of ideas. Two examples of ideology are given
when contributors look at socialism and neoliberalism whilst
political economy tries to give a more dispassionate view (although
its more like capitalism) even if this is less well accepted
today. Globalisation also gets a mention as does one of its
key agents - migration. Part four turns to the construction
of the limits (or bounds) of space. The basic idea here is that
to have a nation (territory) it is essential to define its borders
such that the territory is the space inside the borders. However,
there are two issues with this that need to be discussed. Firstly,
power is essentially aspatial and so its elements might be present
at a range of scales. Alternatively, a border suggests a single
state and this might not be the case (how do we classify the
European Union?). Part five explores the realms of violence.
As an ultimate political force, violence can have a devastating
effect. Today, violence has become recast as 'conflict' whereby
certain groups might attack other groups i.e. violence has moved
partly out of the state and on to a more global setting. Eventually,
conflict subsides and post-conflict situations develop. One
particular variant of current interest is terrorism. It's difficult
to define and to see what its aims are but its influence is
considerable. Finally here we have the notion of anti-statism
- the need to remove the current state and replace it with a
more local form of power. Part six look at one of the most important
aspects of political geography - identity. It argues that power
is taken by a group with an identifiable identity (identifiable,
that is, because there are others who don't have that characteristic).
In this arena nationalism (a given ethnic/religious group in
a given space) has more political resonance than state (a group
of people - citizens) who have rights to stay within that area.
These ideas deal with people how reside in an area. Post-colonialism
on the other hand deals with the removal of some people from
an area (colonists) and the implications both for those left
behind and those who follow to the colonial nation (e.g. unrest
between extremes of colonized nationals and their colonisers).
All of this works only if we can construct an identity that
can be seen by us and by others to be a specific signal (gender,
of course, is a sub-set of this).
As
can be seen above, this is a very densely packed text outlining
the main 28 topics as seen as currently important. Each part
starts with an excellent overview and each chapter is broken
down into main text, key points and further reading. In addition,
each chapter has one or more case studies to illustrate the
main points discussed. As such it represents a key text is the
delimitation and definition of political geography. It is important
that we are familiar with this topic and its theses because
we need to gain a better understanding of how power works (or
doesn't). We cannot argue that no-one is listening about global
warming if we don't understand how best to influence the power
blocks that control access. Overall, a very good, brief overview
of the topic.