Review:
Insects are our most diverse group of animals. This wealth of
biodiversity needs taxonomists to provide the identification
upon which study depends. According to the preface in this text
there is an inverse relationship- increasing biodiversity and
decreasing taxonomists. Such a situation is clearly not tenable
for the former requires more of the latter! To demonstrate how
far we have come and what we still have to do this text highlights
the key issues.
It
starts with two chapters outlining the book and highlighting
the importance of insects in terms of their ecological role,
their use in wider science and interaction with people. From
this point the text is divided into three parts. The first part
gathers contributors who describe insect biodiversity from a
regional/geographic perspective. The selection of examples and
the aspects discussed in each chapter reinforce the editors
earlier comments of the problems of complete coverage. Two near-Arctic
regions are detailed along with tropical rainforest and Africa
and a lone chapter on Australasia. Topics do vary within each
chapter but most often cover issues about biodiversity variations,
taxonomy issues, human impacts and conservation. Part two takes
a similar view but from the perspective of the taxon with examples
ranging from aquatic taxa to lepidoptera. Here the treatment
is far more even with overviews of the key taxa and discussions
on human impact and conservation. Part three covers the largest
number of contributions and issues. Sub-titled tools and approaches
it deals with a range of taxonomic issues. Chapter 14 opens
this section with a discussion on some of the more pressing
issues in taxonomy. It's not just about changes in classification
but far more about the need for taxonomists set against an array
of new computational methods that could transform the subject.
As if these issues were not enough, chapter 15 goes further
to question the whole idea od species and where to draw the
line arguing that there is more than one answer to this. The
following two chapters add to the debate by looking at some
of the new methods available such as molecular ecology and DNA
studies. All this information needs to be organised which is
where the next contribution, dealing with informatics, has its
say. The next avenue to be explored is the issue of pest and
pest control. This is controversial not just because of the
cost of controlling species but the methods used. Biological
control might seem ideal but it can (and in Australia, has)
get out of control. On another tack, parasites that control
pests may not travel when the insect species invades another
place. Also parasites have their own biodiversity which needs
to be protected. Finally in this set there's a look at biting
flies. It's too simple to just remove them because some are
harmless or even useful and anyway, as we see here, we can learn
a lot about species control by more careful study. What we have
in these four chapters is a very complex view about insect pests
- far from the simple idea of just removing them. If anything,
after studying these chapters, the reader will come away with
a sense of the multi-facetted nature of insect ecology and the
value of more research. The final three chapters all focus on
biodiversity and conservation arguing about insect values, uses,
biodiversity management and the sheer size of the problem we
need to address.
This
is a highly specialised and complex book dealing with a specific
group of animals. It is also a very interesting exploration
of the issues surrounding the seemingly simple notion of biodiversity.
Although obviously aimed at the expert, it can also be used
by those studying other organismal groups. The wealth of ideas
could also spread to broader educational settings like senior
school work and field centres. It's one of those texts which
needs a wider readership than might be envisaged because its
message, although difficult to penetrate at times, is one with
universal application.