Review:
For many years the Worldwatch Institute have been putting together
the most important issues of that year and discussing their
implications. This year sees their 25th edition which makes
it one of the longest running and most respected yearbook. Each
year there is a theme and this year its the advantages in building
sustainable economies.
As
always, the choice of focus is commendable. There are numerous
forces arguing, just like the lead-in-petrol debate 25 years
earlier, that it's not possible to have an booming sustainable
economy and there is something in that even if it's just on
the philosophical level that no growth is inexhaustible. As
with recent years we start the book with a timeline of key environmental
events. It covers a range of activities, both negative and positive
that affect the environment. It acts as a reminder of events
past and serves highlight issues that might be arising. Chapter
one sets the scene by examining the ways by which we can start
the new sustainable economy. Unlike the grander earlier schemes,
this argues for a more cautious approach using targeted responses
to economic needs. Chapter two critiques the various measures
used to define 'progress' and suggests which might be most applicable
for the future. Chapter three takes the basic capitalist idea
of production and outlines how it can be made more acceptable.
It's an interesting take on an old issue because it discusses
not just the processes but the financing and theory surrounding
it. It's not just production that needs examination: chapter
four focusses on lifestyles pointing out, quite rightly, that
a US-type lifestyle cannot be global but that it is possible
to improve people's standards by other ways. Continuing with
the personal side, chapter five examines the demand for protein,
specifically meat and seafood which are both energy inefficient
and degrading of ecosystems. There are many ways of looking
at this idea of sustainability and the one that gets most press
currently is carbon. Chapters six and seven focus on various
issues with the former looking at the production side and the
latter the financial market solution. This last chapter not
only carries on the previous topic but also opens up a mini-section
in the middle of the book. Entitled 'paying for nature's services'
the three chapters tackle key issues. The idea of markets for
carbon has already been mentioned. It's based on the idea that
only when we put a value on something will it be managed (harking
back to the 'tragedy of the commons' argument). This area is
booming but time will tell if it is actually doing the job hoped
of it. The other two chapters look at water supply and biodiversity.
The former argues that water needs to be taken out of its narrow
market confines. This approach rarely gives water its proper
value in terms of ecosystem services. Likewise, biodiversity
conservation can actually do more harm than good. What all three
are arguing for is a greater mainstream acceptance of the need
to re-think our economic stances and processes. Moving outside
this special section, chapter 10 deals with non-capitalist ways
of allocating resources. The case study of water allocation
given here is one such way and contrasts very sharply with the
conflicting situation in places like Australia. The final four
chapters act as two pairs. The first pair looks at one of the
most under-utilised resources - people, and argues for a greater
say for communities through politics (community action) and
local resource use. The last pair takes a look at the financial
side of sustainability noting that we still need to run an economic
system but should be able to do it with less damage than at
present.
Again,
this book stands out. The chapters are all well-written and
sourced. They are brief enough to provide a concise overview
without missing vital points but at the same time brief enough
to allow the reader to gain a swift understanding of the topic.
Issues are current. There are no specific viewpoints being proposed
(if one discounts the notion that something needs to be done!).
The editors maintain an useful mix of caution, warning and optimism.
It stands alone as the single most useful annual on the world's
environmental issues. It should be mandated for education and
ecology/environment courses. Make sure your library has at least
one of these books!