Review:
Much has been written about the relationship between nature
and the city (much of it negative) but of late there has been
a new movement developing - the notion of urban-as-ecosystem.
It takes the city and treats it as another ecosystem (as in
urban ecology) or at least as another series of niches to be
used. This is an interesting development to say the least because
it gets away from the less useful, more negative images and
since we are now an urbanised planet such approaches are overdue.
Most of these studies start from an ecological perspective but
this text, although covering similar ground, starts from an
urban geographical perspective.
Written
by two eminent urban geographers this book is an attempt to
show the city/nature interface and what it means for both sides
of the story. It does this by dividing the book into three parts
corresponding, roughly, with past, present and future. Part
one looks at the way in which 'nature' and 'city' have been
related. We start with an outline of key terms and an overview
of the main points to be raised in the book. Chapter two shows
how the city developed and, alongside that, how the environment
was brought into (or kept out of) the city area. So, we have
plans with rivers and forests as positives and designed areas
and disease which would be the negative. It's fair to say that
until the 19th century, the equation swayed unevenly between
the two. The industrial town, as shown in chapter three, swung
the balance very much in favour of the city with the environment
being very much a case of pollution and degradation. Parisian
sewers and dead American horses highlight our not very glorious
city past. However, set against this we have the new reforms
from the parks movement to the more radical garden city design.
Chapter four brings us up to date in terms of history, but with
a continuing divide in cities. This time though it's not between
nature and city but between 'developed' and 'developing' city.
The developed city is going through a post-industrial transformation
from grimy city to parkland wonder. Its megacity cousin in the
developing world is going, so it seems, in the other direction
with slums and poor water supply just two issues. There tends
to be less of a consideration that the developed nations went
through this 150 years ago and that perhaps what we are seeing
today is less a new phenomenon than an old one with reporters!
Part two looks at a range of environmental issues. Chapter five
looks at the specific site of cities and what it means in terms
of city-nature relations. Chapter six considers the city and
hazards - how people respond to disasters from fires to Hurricane
Katrina. Chapter seven turns to another contemporary issue -
the ecofootprint - and demonstrates how cities live well outside
their physical boundaries. The final three chapters study the
key environmental issues of our times in terms of water, air,
and land pollution or, more accurately, sewage and supply, smog
and garbage. Clearly the advantages of city living don't extend
to consideration of the environment. Of course, this may well
change as part three, looking at future city-nature relations
suggests. Thus chapter 11 considers the issue of urban equity,
especially race and environment with the argument that the worst
conditions are lived in by those least able to escape them.
Chapter 12 considers the idea of sustainability and ways in
which the city can grow and prosper at the same time as using
fewer resources more effectively. A brief postscript returns
to the themes of the introduction to consider ways forward.
Overall,
a very useful book. It describes the city in an environmental
context and shows how we have used that environment, for good
or ill, through the centuries. It's a good introduction to the
topic which, when used in conjunction with the extra resources
mentioned, will provide a decent overview of both the past and
the future. We are becoming an urban planet, the sooner we realise
the implications of this the better - this text will help in
this endeavour.