Review:
At first glance one could be forgiven thinking that what we
really need now is another climate book. Yes, we know we're
responsible for enhanced global warming and all the effects
so we don't want to have the whole story re-hashed. The problem
is that this isn't the whole story by any means. Only 30 years
ago it was acceptable (actually, necessary) to teach the 'ice-age'
hypothesis whereby pollution shut out incoming radiation and
the Earth cools. Only a few cranks on the fringes would mention
a complementary hypothesis called the 'greenhouse effect' whereby
the same pollution would keep heat in! Then, of course there
were the problems with the Russians modifying our climate to
let their tanks win in Europe. If you haven't lived through
this its hard to believe but, sadly, it's true. The real problem
is that once global warming got a kick start it has acted like
a juggernaut with all other aspects put to one side. This
is why we need this book and what it's trying to say.
Put
simply, this is a book that points out all human foibles regarding
modern relationships with the atmosphere. In so doing it puts
the global warming debate in a better perspective than many
other, dedicated, texts. Here we can see how and why there are
issues with global warming and why the picture, although virtually
certain, is not 100% and may never be. However, we do start
with the Russians or at least with their counterparts, the Americans
trying to get rain out of clouds. Called 'cloud seeding' it
is based on the Bergeron-Findeisen process of droplet formation
via nuclei. The whole story and a few offshoots occupies the
first part of this three-part book. We start with the briefest
of overviews before launching into the complementary rise (chapter
two) and fall (chapter three) of cloud seeding and their relatives,
hail suppression and cyclone slowing. Part two looks more at
the mainstream ideas of climate change through inadvertent impacts
i.e. as byproducts of human activity. Chapter four examines
the changes wrought by aircraft, ships and dust. This is followed
by an description of changes caused by urban areas - not just
heat island but other impacts such as changes in wind speed
and direction. Chapter five continues this theme but for several
other human activities e.g. landscape changes, irrigation, agriculture
and deforestation. A two-page summary closes the section. Part
three is the big topic - global warming. However, rather than
take an overall summary, key aspects are taken in turn. The
first of these is the effect of changes on the climate system.
Taking the two elements - radiation and feedback - the human
and natural changes are described along with the views of the
IPCC on them. Chapter 9 introduces the impact of aerosols on
clouds and what this means in terms of energy flow. Chapter
10 takes a turn in another direction completely with an examination
of an idea popular about 15 years ago - nuclear winters. This
is the notion that global nuclear warfare would produce so much
dust and smoke that it would blot out the sun and cause dramatic
reduction in heat. It might be a moot point to see if anyone
would be alive to check the findings at this point but at least
we can examine smaller impacts to see changes on a local scale.
Finally, there's a chance to see how land use changes affect
global warming. An epilogue brings together a range of brief
comments that are intriguing leaving one to wonder why they
weren't in the body of the text. The role of natural variability
(a big issue in climate "denial") gains a mention
as does science and marketing, public relations and politics.
The
value of this book lies in the treatment it gives to a very
wide range of subjects. It does not fall into the trap or arguing
that every change is about global warming. It highlights a wider
and greater interest of humans in modifying the atmosphere (or
trying to) with varying degrees of success. The scope and the
even handedness of argument makes this a very important book.
In places it's a tough read for students but there's enough
to make them interested in widening their thinking of topics
of global change. Overall, an excellent addition to the debate
on atmosphere modification.