Review:
The debate surrounding energy and global warming is increasing
in both amount and, it seems at time, bile. As educators what
we need is a good source of information to examine competing
ideas and to show students what sort of questions need to be
asked. In this text we have one element covered that has received
too little exposure of late - the physics of energy. Before
anyone wonders what a 'physics' text might be doing on an ecology
site, some explanation is due.
One
of the key points that can only increase in importance is the
need to have a range of energy sources available for us to use.
Fossil fuels are obviously not viable long-term and the nuclear
option is still to difficult for many (even though there are
reactors which do have a high degree of safety and efficiency).
This means that many people grab the 'renewable' option and
assume that this will produce some sort of energy paradise.
Of course it won't but in the process we need to be aware of
which options might be more useful. This is where the physics
comes in - asking the key energy questions from which we can
then make choices. Chapter one outlines the history of energy
and notes the impact of the greenhouse effect on the need to
question energy use. Subsequent chapters examine specific energy
options. For example, chapter two studies thermal energy. Key
heat transfer devices are seen but the analysis focusses on
energy efficiency and energy calculations and here lies the
value of this text. It assumes that the basic designs, issues
etc. can be found elsewhere: this text focusses on the energy
equations - which form of engine is better for steam turbines
etc. The treatment is quite mathematical as one might expect
but there are worked examples and the equations/graphs are within
the range of any competent student. Chapter three turns the
attention to fluids as part of the examination of turbines and
as a prelude to chapter four which looks at water power. Here
there is a stunning range of devices which are described in
terms of both design and efficiency. A similar quality of explanation
is found in the next chapter which turns its attention to wind
power. There's much here that is reminiscent of early alternative
energy education material although its nice to see it upgraded
to cover the intervening years. Solar energy is next with a
look not just at current designs but also those in trial or
design stages. Biomass is the focus of chapter seven which studies
the topic from both primary and waste angles. Fission and fusion
might be out of favour (or in the latter's case still in design)
but they still can contribute. A thoughtful chapter on the pros
and cons of reactor design helps the former whilst the latter's
design and maths make it one of the more challenging chapters.
Chapter 10 covers issues surrounding the generation and distribution
of electricity through conventional wires and fuel cells. A
final, too brief, chapter examines a wide range of social issues
surrounding energy usage such as carbon trading and life cycle
analysis.
This
is a very useful text. Apart from the range of topics noted
above, each chapter is packed with educational material starting
with a topic list and ending with excellent summaries, readings,
web links, exercises (and answers). Its value lies in the degree
to which the science of energy is inter-linked with issues of
safety, environment etc. For those aiming to deal with this
area in more detail than normally found, this is a very good
place to start.