Review:
The rise of conservation ecology and biology books has been
obvious to anyone looking at this field over the last ten years.
What seems to be in shorter supply is the text that looks at
issues. Early in the development of this field we had works
by researchers such as Dasmann and Piggott which attempted to
answer the philosophical issues facing us but since then, the
casual reader could be forgiven for thinking that these problems
had been resolved and that all that was needed was for a few
loose ends to be cleared up. Of course, nothing is further from
the truth - at a time when conservation is being challenged
increasingly, we need students who have a grasp of the entire
topic.
This
text aims to fill the gap. It starts by arguing a case for the
book - a case based on the urgent need to control biodiversity
(especially losses) and the idea that the process of conservation
is intrinsically interesting. Thus the reader is targeted in
two ways - to see the topic as important and to see the way
in which leading workers view the key areas in conservation.
We start the substantive work with an overview of the idea of
biodiversity, problems of loss and the reasons this matters.
Chapter two argues for making priorities in conservation - that
certain approaches are inherently more useful than others. If
the idea of prioritization is one that people feel should not
be in a conservation text then the next chapter will disabuse
them fast! Whatever we wish to see, it's a reality that conservation
is best served by considering the economics of the situation.
As the contributors rightly state, morals and ethics are fine
but its money that will win more arguments. Luckily the notion
of ecosystem services (e.g. Constanza) is becoming more entrenched
in our thinking and we can respond more readily. Chapter four
looks at a technique which has had a considerable impact on
our thinking. Genetic analysis has allowed us to view relationships
we might not have been able to see but it also makes us question
the whole nature of biodiversity and what it means to be a species.
Another area of study is the population. Whereas it's amenable
to study it also might not be a representative fraction (harking
back to the previous chapter). Chapter six gets away from the
biological scene to consider the role of climate change. Rather
than join in the vast array of literature on this, this chapter
focusses on the immediate challenge we need to face - that the
physical environment might change faster than species can adapt.
In facing these problems we need all the help we can get. Technology
has a great role to play but it's not perfect as chapter seven
points out. The next issue facing us is welfare. Here the argument
is that to be successful we need to look at the ethical dimensions.
It's not just a moral issue - some endangered species have been
negatively impacted by poor or inappropriate handling. To continue
the range of ideas, chapter 10 turns to the role of conservation
groups and governments in pursuing the goal of conservation.
That this is focussed in the tropics is appropriate because
it is clear that future problems will occur around current biodiversity
hotspots. The role of pests is a difficult subject. On the one
hand they are organisms like any other and so conservation should
be considered. On the other hand they control or even remove
species if not handled well. Both chapters 11 and 12 look at
the problems surrounding this - the former in terms of parasites'
impact on population numbers; the latter in terms of these (vertebrate)
numbers themselves reaching pest proportions and needing control.
This theme is extended into chapter 13 where the role and impact
of introduced species is examined. The old bumper sticker -
preserve wildlife, pickle a squirrel - was meant to be a satire
on the need to conserve biodiversity. Today, as chapter 14 shows,
it's more than likely to be a reality as bushmeat (notably,
but not exclusively) from the tropics is used to supplement
both diet and income. This might be seen as sacrilege by some
but it's just another area to be considered as conservation
biology continues to expand its reach and develop its topic
area. Likewise, hunting (chapter 15) can both help and hinder
wildlife (a case, or at least the former, often being put by
farmers in pro-hunt arguments). Farmers also make their presence
felt in the next chapter where the old argument of farming or
wildlife is now far more often farming and wildlife.
Part of the old antipathy for wildlife is analysed in chapter
17 where wildlife encroachment often damages those sections
of the population least able to bear it i.e. rural poor. A final
chapter seeks to draw broad conclusions from the diverse papers.
Overall,
this is an outstanding text. It brings the old ideas of conservation
philosophy up to date. It also highlights the most important
areas in this burgeoning subject area. Most importantly, it
tells the story in accessible terms and with a refreshing vigour
that many other texts would do well to emulate. This is probably
one the the best recent books on this area of work. It deserves
the widest readership and should be a 'must-buy' text for the
library both institutional and personal.