Review:
According to the information on the back cover, the last edition
was rated highly by this reviewer! It's always a bit daunting
to see this and also, one realises that there's the responsibility
to see if the new edition lives up to the old promise. For those
with the old edition the good news is that changes are largely
statistical with a few new areas (notably migration and America).
Those new to this edition should start below.
Population
is a key subject with more than its fair share of data. Whilst
such wealth of information is good it comes with the problem
of trying to make some sense out of the data. Given that population
is also a highly political subject it follows that there's also
a need to chart some reasonable course through the debate. Rather
than tackle all areas of population change, this text looks
at one area - world population change - but chooses to do so
in a multi-disciplinary way. The result is a brief but thorough
overview. We start with a basic description of key demographic
ideas. This goes from r and k strategies we share with all organisms
through to human demographic changes and the space needed to
carry them out. As such this chapter sets the scene for subsequent
discussions. Chapter two analyses the major changes in population
numbers - Neolithic, Industrial Revolution and current population
"booms" and assesses the impact that they have had.
This shows population changes as affected by environmental causes.
Population also has a balance between resources and numbers.
There are two opposing views here depending on whether resources
drive population or the opposite. The problem ,as chapter three
makes clear, is that neither has the upper hand and so this
area, of great concern, remains a mystery. Up to this point,
population is seem as being constrained by environmental or
resource factors. Chapter four looks at a basic idea of human
demography - the demographic transition theory - and highlights
the changes it causes. The idea is that this "theory"
(probably more accurately a hypothesis!) is something seen in
all nations but at different times. This does suggest that even
current high population nations will eventually reduce their
growth rate. This is very much a case for the richer countries.
Chapter fives turns the spotlight onto poorer countries. It
follows much the same ground as in the previous chapter but
gives more weight to country examples e.g. India and China.
A final chapter looks at the some of the issues that are/may
arise in global demographics. Here, the latest population projections
are subjected to scrutiny. For those wanting more, there is
a series of appendices containing detailed notes and references.
In
the intervening years between editions this book has lost none
of its impact. It is still a significant comment on contemporary
demographic thought. It highlights key debates and issues rather
than bury them. There's a use of examples, many not commonly
used, that give a freshness to the debate and illustrate that
arguments can be drawn from new material. It does lose some
depth but then this is an overview and what it loses is more
than made up by the debate it seeks to engender. Overall, this
is still a significant contribution to the debate which should
be seen as a must-buy for those wanting a more sophisticated
level of debate in contemporary demographics.