Review:
Geographic Information Systems (GIS) have been with us for some
time but until now they have been kept mainly to the realms
of academia. The advent of programs such as WorldWind
and Google
Earth has brought spatial awareness to mass audiences. Add
the range of mashups
(linkages of data and maps often from different sources) that
are available as well as sites offering to host spatial data
and you have the ingredients for a revolution in spatial awareness
amongst the general public. Today it's important that we emphasise
the value of GIS not just in terms of ecological and environmental
education but also in terms of wider community use.
When
this book was first published in 1998 the introduction above
might have seemed far-fetched. Today, we need to use this new
technology to improve not only education but the environment
as well. Despite the increasing interest in GIS (even the journal
Nature has devoted space to extolling GIS's virtues to education)
there would still be a need to learn more about the basics of
the system. This third edition is well placed to capitalise
on this recent interest. The book is divided into two sections
dealing with fundamentals and issues. The first section, looking
at fundamental aspects starts, appropriately enough with an
overview of what GIS is (and is not) and what it can do (and
can't!). It sets the scene for the material to follow. Chapter
two focusses on the types of data that can be used in GIS and
how this can be output. This might seem abstract but it is fundamental
to the process. One could make the analogy with a car - it's
possible to drive knowing nothing about the mechanics but it's
far better to see how it works and when it might not. Chapter
three looks at how data can be output as either raster or vector
along with more advanced techniques. From this we move to the
database to see how it is structured. Chapter five takes the
process one stage further to explore how data can be input into
the system (often the slowest part and one where student interest
might flag) as well as the range of outputs that can be obtained.
The last three chapters in this section focus on the business
end of GIS - getting the data out. Here is the really interesting
part - data can be input into the GIS but it is the system's
ability to rapidly restructure parameters and alter answers
that makes it so invaluable to all areas of our work from management
to science. Previously such data were available and would be
put onto maps. Overlays could be added and then key areas extracted
manually according to need. GIS does away with all this by virtue
of its processing capacity and ability to more accurately interrogate
the data. Part two looks at some of the issues that have been
raised about GIS. Although it is "just" a computer
software package its ability to affect our decision making in
profound ways is such that we need to be aware of some of the
surrounding debate. Thus chapter 9 shows how we got into this
situation via paper maps and how this influences our thinking.
Chapter 10 describes the range of data errors that can plague
GIS - it's ability to handle large data sets is also its main
weakness: huge quantities of poor data is still a poor result
however much the program manipulates it. Chapter 11 scales up
the issues from individual users to corporations and shows what
needs to be considered. Next, we see how GIS can be brought
into management although, as it's made clear, we need to know
what we are looking for first. A final chapter discusses the
future of GIS.
There
is much to admire in this text. Alongside the information about
GIS there's a wealth of educational input that makes the text
one of the best teaching aids in this topic area (as one would
expect from authors with key distance learning experience).
Each chapter has a series of educational aids - outcome lists,
a range of text boxes to focus on key areas or features (theory,
case studies, reflection areas, questions, references and web
resources). In addition, there's a book website
with quizzes, a glossary, student and teacher sections (the
latter yet to be implemented). Overall, a very impressive aid
to understanding and one that deserves a wide readership.