Review:
Despite the amount of interest in larger herbivores there remains
limited collected information about their ecology and conservation.
The aim of this text is to gather a range of material to better
highlight key issues. Behind this is the notion that conservation
should be based on scientific evidence. As such, this book represents
the results of a conference in 2002 to consider such matters.
The
book starts with a brief introduction on the nature of herbivores
and their place in the ecosystem. Although the focus is on Eurasian
herbivores and their conservation
programmes. As if to counter this, the first chapter reviews
the roles of large herbivores across a range of biomes defining
'large' as >5kg and showing how a range of factors from distribution
to body size varies. Chapter two looks at the responses of herbivores
to Arctic ecosystems arguing that populations have adapted to
seasonal changes and that global warming might upset population
dynamics. Chapter three focusses on the key relationship between
herbivore and plant - foraging. By reviewing the evidence on
foraging patterns it becomes clear that there is a complex relationship
between food and eater which some current models do not explore
well. Chapter four explores the impacts both negative (food
supply) and positive (seed dispersal) of herbivores on shrub
populations. Chapter five explores the relationship between
herbivores in plants in arid areas. Despite low densities due
to extreme conditions there is still the idea that long-term
herbivory can lead to land degradation. However, as this review
shows, the actual picture appears to be more complex with food
preferences altering ecology and rainfall playing an important
part. Chapter six discusses the role of herbivores in woodlands
outlining the complex relationships between animals and plant
communities and noting that balance can be altered by increased
stocking rates - a clear reference to African conservation successes.
Such complexity can be seen elsewhere as chapter seven looks
at the relationship between herbivores and European forests
with the addition here of human activity. This suggests that
conservation based on 'naturalness' might need to be redefined
in light of human uses of woodland. If herbivores can influence
forest composition then it can also be shown to impact upon
certain tree species through frugivory especially in warmer
areas. Chapter 10 describes changes to nutrient cycles, especially
Nitrogen, through animal activity and waste with chapter 11
continuing the theme for Nitrogen by examining changes in grasslands.
The final chapters shift emphasis from ecology more to management
and conservation. Thus chapter 12 examines the accuracy of models.
Chapter 13 shows that success by large herbivores can come at
the expense of smaller herbivores. Chapter 14 examines different
perspectives on herbivore impact by researchers working in Northern
latitudes: the implication being that conservation needs to
examine these areas especially in terms of re-introduction.
Finally there are two chapters looking firstly at the ecosystem
conservation and secondly on the ways in which systematic study
can and advance our understanding.
This
is a useful text focussing upon a single animal group to better
understand its ecology and ethology. The range of ideas is considerable.
This synthesis of current knowledge would be most useful for
undergraduate ecologists and those with a specialised interest
in herbivores. As such it should be seen as a key text for this
group.