Review:
The idea of a global cities book in an ecological site might,
at first, seem unusual. However, there is much to recommend
it. Put simply, global cities are a new phenomenon which appear
to be able to dictate events outside their physical area - i.e.
their ecological
footprint goes well beyond their own boundaries. It follows
that if we are concerned about environmental matters then we
need to understand the forces that create and sustain these
cities. to this end, this reader - a collection of key contributions
- is a vital start. The idea of the global city may not be new!
The actual starting point, depending on who you select it seems,
can be as far back as 1915 or more recently, the late 1980s.
Likewise, the definition of the global city is far from fixed
and their are numerous disagreements on matters ranging from
theory to practice. What we have here is a vibrant field of
study just beginning to see the parameters of its work.
To
illustrate the work in this field the editors have assembled
50 contributions that span the main ideas and whose work can
be seen as highlighting key points. Each one has been edited
highly which has the advantage of condensing the material but
the disadvantage of letting some of the finer points escape
the readers attention. Against this one has a wide variety of
views and each chapter has good bibliography so that any particular
area can be explored in more detail. We start with an exploration
of the concept of the global city. Peter Hall starts off the
section with an historical perspective of early works on global
city formation which is complemented by a range of other studies
all of which started to encapsulate the new ideas. Part two
starts with the idea of global cities as the sites for transnational
headquarters - one of the first key ideas to become established
in this area. Initial links to globalisation are seen and developed
such that the global city becomes an essential part of the global
system of capital - a necessary fixed point around which decentralisation
of national resources can occur. Part three examines the way
in which a seemingly un-related problem - urban decline - turned
into an "urban renaissance" through gentrification
and place-time specific economic features. The 1970s and 1980s
were times of urban decline and this was largely accepted. However,
the rise of globalisation and the re-use of the city centre
provided an impetus for older cities to reinvent themselves,
often aided by historical factors. If work to this point were
mapped there would be a very heavy focus on Europe and North
America. In many respects this was reasonable as these areas
were the first to experience global cities. However, it can
also be seen as an exercise in power - the global North taking
all the research leaving the global South, yet again, as terra
incognita. Part four aims to redress the balance; to show
that there is much to be gained from studying cities outside
the "Western" tradition. This is not just a case of
recognising the megacity but of an intellectual shift away from
the duality of "global city" and "empty space"
to a greater recognition that all cities are situated within
an active local milieu (the work of GaWC
is often cited here). Like part three, cities discussed here
are subject to global forces but they also have common links
(such as colonialism) making this area od research a fascinating
one. Part five moves on to social themes - specifically urban
politics. Global cites were originally thought to be places
of control, where an urban elite held sway and the masses were
excluded from the benefits of globalisation. This view, as we
see here, has been tempered by more research which shows, alongside
physical restructuring, there has been a political restructuring
providing a range of responses for the new urban citizen. Part
six continues the human theme by exploring the nature of culture.
One of the key ideas behind the global city was the creativity
that it brought to the place. This was best seen, it was argued,
through a multicultural perspective. However, as we see in these
readings, not only is the notion of multiculturalism under attack
so is the whole idea of culture and how these can be discussed
within an urban context. The final part, seven, gathers more
recent readings which together form a critique of current research
and a suggestion of ways it could proceed.
This
is a fascinating text. The depth and breadth of the contributions
are such that it provides readers with a stimulating insight
into this important research field whilst at the same time allowing
them to follow up on any areas found to be of particular interest.
The abbreviation of the contributions turns out to be a bonus
rather than a hindrance - the multiple facets of the subject
can be laid out without becoming mired down in detail. As such
it should be regarded as an essential text for urban courses.
From the perspective of wider study, the focus on power, culture
and global economies shows where researchers are going but the
lack of environmental concern points to an avenue yet to be
explored. As ecologists, if we complain about the lack of attention,
perhaps we ought to start matching the research!