Review:
The need for a genetic analysis of conservation populations
has been appreciated for many years in both theory and practice
(e.g. zoo breeding registers). What has changed recently is
the move towards a better understanding of the place that theory
occupies in our studies and how this can be translated into
better conservation. However urgent we realise matters are,
finance will always be limited and it becomes incumbent upon
us to select the most effective options - hence the need to
explore fully the genetic picture put in front of us.
This
text aims to provide a detailed overview for the conservationist
or university student who wishes to study in more detail the
role that genetic analysis can play. To accomplish this, the
text is divided into three. The first part acts as an introduction
to genetics. Although some knowledge of biological science is
expected this is still an introductory text so the first four
chapters explore the basics of the topic. The first chapter
starts with the fundamental questions as to why we should conserve,
and what. It also places the role of genetics in conservation
so that we are left in no doubt of its importance. Chapter two
considers the value of phenotypic variation which is one of
the central points - variation is crucial for viable populations
and that is, by definition, the one thing most likely to be
missing in restricted conservation populations. Chapters three
and four discuss the main areas of genetic variation and how
they can be assessed and used in conservation. Part two moves
us into the body of the work by looking at genetics in more
detail. As such these 8 chapters prepare us for the final section
which seeks to apply this knowledge. Thus early chapters here
look at mating sequences and losses in genetic material due
to restricted populations. Since both of these conditions will
apply to conservation populations it makes sense to start here.
Chapter seven moves on to another key question - how big should
the conservation population be? It's the notion of viable population
size but applied through the lens of genetics which suggests,
if recent research is anything to go by, that we need to be
far more careful about the populations we pick and the sizes
they demand. Now that we can actually measure variation, questions
like these become crucial. Much of this work assumes that natural
selection does not operate. It keeps the model simple but fails
to help in real situations. Therefore, chapter 8 introduces
us to some of the likely variations. Chapter 9 moves this idea
logically forward arguing that the outcome of natural selection
is variation both between and within populations, both of which
need to be taken into account. The picture is further complicated
by the inclusion of multiple nuclei (chapter 10). All this work
needs to be put into some form of statistical framework. Finally,
there's the notion of mutation. Up to this point, certain elements
have been kept constant to allow the reader to better appreciate
the key points. Here, we introduce the idea of mutation and
what it means to conservation populations. Part three puts this
theory into practice. If the aim is to have a viable representative
population then it requires considerable manipulation. Just
how much is now becoming clearer as we can assess our work at
a number of levels. We start with one problem - inbreeding and
the problems it can create. Chapter 14 examines the population
size mentioned in part two but from the conservation, not genetic,
perspective. Again, sub-populations are good to study but fragmented
populations can cause a range of difficulties in terms of viability
and fitness. It's left for chapter 16 to actually ask what one
might have considered to be a central point earlier in the text
- at what scale do we take conservation? If, as has been argued
up to now, we need viable genetic populations then it follows
that we should be more careful about our choice (a point numerous
recent research papers have agreed with). One way out of population
pressure is by breeding and chapters 17 and 18 tackle this issue
form the genetic angle. So far, we have assumed that the population
is in trouble but not any specific cause. Chapter 19 introduces
and increasingly common one, the invasive species. This can
cause a range of problems and not just in loss of wildlife but
also a re-distribution of relative sizes and locations. A final
chapter shows how genetic analysis can aid identification (useful
in, say, smuggling cases).
This
is a great introduction. It is definitely a text where some
previous knowledge is important but there are still good points
that can be gleaned by the more casual reader. As such this
is a good text for educators but its main focus will be conservation
courses where its logical layout and mixture of theory and application
should find ready readers.